Airline Executives Defend Seat Fees Amid Senate Scrutiny

Written by

U.S. airline executives faced tough questions from a Senate panel on Wednesday regarding seat selection fees, which critics have labeled as “junk fees.” Over the past five years, these fees have generated billions in revenue for the airline industry, sparking a heated debate over their fairness and transparency.

Table of Contents

Billions in Revenue from Seat Fees

Between 2018 and 2023, American, Delta, United, Spirit, and Frontier Airlines collectively earned $12.4 billion from seat selection fees, according to a report by the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations. These fees include charges for seats with extra legroom, those closer to the front of the plane, and preferred window or aisle seats.

Senator Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.), who chairs the subcommittee, criticized the practice in prepared remarks, saying, “Airlines these days view their customers as little more than walking piggy banks to be shaken down for every possible dime.”

Airlines Push Back

Airline executives defended the fees, emphasizing that they offer flexibility and affordability to travelers.

Stephen Johnson, American Airlines’ chief strategy officer, stated that seat selection products are voluntary. “For customers who value sitting in more in-demand locations, we do offer the opportunity to pay for more desirable seats,” he said in his testimony.
Andrew Nocella, United Airlines’ chief commercial officer, argued that the fee-based model provides options for budget-conscious travelers. “A one-size-fits-all travel model would deny lower-cost options to our customers,” he said, referencing United’s Basic Economy fares, which allow passengers to skip paying for services they don’t need.

United recently adjusted its policy to exempt families with children under 12 from seat selection fees for preferred seats, a move applauded by some lawmakers.

The Debate Over Transparency

Executives defended their communication strategies, stating that pricing information is clearly displayed during the booking process.

“Fares requiring a fee to select a seat are denoted with a symbol, indicating that extra legroom or a different fare class comes at an additional cost,” Johnson explained.
Airlines have also highlighted their efforts to offer multiple tiers of economy service, allowing passengers to choose the level of comfort and amenities they prefer.

High-End Seating Takes Off

While budget fares remain a priority for many passengers, airlines have been expanding their offerings of premium seating to meet growing demand. Larger, more luxurious seats with extra legroom are a popular option for travelers willing to pay more for comfort.

Budget Airlines Under Pressure

Discounters like Spirit Airlines and Frontier Airlines were among the first to introduce the fee-based model, which has since been adopted by larger carriers. However, Spirit’s recent challenges—including a failed merger with JetBlue and increased competition—led the airline to file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in November.

Despite their low base fares, budget airlines face growing scrutiny over the rising cost of add-ons, such as seat selection and baggage fees.

Moving Forward

The Senate hearing underscored the ongoing tension between airline profitability and customer satisfaction. Lawmakers are pushing for greater transparency and fairness, while airlines maintain that their tiered pricing models offer passengers more choice and affordability.

As the debate continues, travelers should expect clearer pricing disclosures—but likely not an end to the fees that have become a cornerstone of the airline industry’s revenue model.