15 Caribbean Islands That Aren’t Overrun With Tourists

Written by

The Caribbean is full of beautiful islands, but some are so popular they can feel crowded and commercial. If you’re looking for laid-back beaches, quiet towns, and authentic island vibes without the cruise ship crowds, you’re in luck. These hidden gems offer turquoise waters, soft sand, and peace and quiet—just what a true island escape should be.

Here are 15 Caribbean islands that are still off the radar (but probably won’t be for long).

Table of Contents

1. Dominica

Known as the “Nature Island,” Dominica is a paradise for hikers, waterfall chasers, and eco-travelers. Instead of mega-resorts, you’ll find lush rainforests, bubbling hot springs, and black-sand beaches that are rarely crowded. The island is home to the Caribbean’s longest hiking trail and some of its most pristine diving spots. For those craving adventure and untouched nature, Dominica offers a peaceful escape with authentic island charm.

2. Saba

Tiny, steep, and incredibly scenic, Saba is one of the Caribbean’s best-kept secrets. Though it lacks sandy beaches, it makes up for it with rugged hiking trails, vibrant coral reefs, and a charming, close-knit community. The island’s only town, called “The Bottom,” is filled with gingerbread houses and friendly locals. It’s a perfect retreat for divers, nature lovers, and anyone seeking tranquility far from the tourist trail.

3. Bequia, St. Vincent & the Grenadines

Bequia offers an old-school Caribbean experience with its quiet beaches, pastel buildings, and gentle pace. This laid-back island is popular with sailors and yachters, but rarely crowded with tourists. You can stroll along the Belmont Walkway, mingle with locals in Port Elizabeth, or relax under the palms on Princess Margaret Beach. Bequia feels like a forgotten paradise where time slows down and simplicity reigns.

4. Guadeloupe

As a French overseas territory, Guadeloupe blends Creole culture with French sophistication. The archipelago features stunning beaches, rainforest-covered mountains, and charming seaside towns. Hike to the top of La Soufrière volcano or browse vibrant markets for baguettes and spices. Despite its beauty and accessibility, Guadeloupe remains under-the-radar for many North American travelers.

5. Montserrat

Montserrat is a volcanic island still shaped by its 1995 eruption, which buried the capital city in ash. Today, the northern part of the island is green, safe, and incredibly peaceful. You can explore black-sand beaches, hike in the Centre Hills forest reserve, or take a guided tour of the ghost town of Plymouth. It’s an island with a haunting history and resilient charm.

6. Grenada

Nicknamed the “Spice Island,” Grenada is fragrant with nutmeg, cinnamon, and cloves—and it smells as good as it looks. The island is full of cascading waterfalls, tropical hikes, and uncrowded beaches. Grand Anse Beach is the best-known stretch of sand, but even it remains blissfully uncrowded. Grenada is ideal for travelers who want Caribbean beauty with a dash of culture and warmth.

7. Saint Eustatius (Statia)

Statia is a tiny Dutch Caribbean island that few travelers know about, but those who visit often return. It’s known for its fantastic diving, hiking trails up the dormant volcano The Quill, and quiet historic charm. With no big resorts or flashy attractions, the island has preserved its old Caribbean atmosphere. If you like peace, authenticity, and nature, this one’s for you.

8. Tobago

Tobago, the smaller sibling of Trinidad, is full of natural beauty and relaxed vibes. Its lush rainforests, coral reefs, and fishing villages create a laid-back, welcoming environment. You can snorkel in Buccoo Reef, birdwatch in the Main Ridge Forest Reserve, or simply nap on a secluded beach. It’s Caribbean slow-living at its finest.

9. Marie-Galante, Guadeloupe

Just a short ferry ride from the main islands of Guadeloupe, Marie-Galante is peaceful, flat, and dotted with rum distilleries and sugarcane fields. It’s ideal for travelers who want to step off the tourist path and enjoy a truly local vibe. The beaches are wide and empty, the food is flavorful, and the pace is blissfully slow. Marie-Galante is as unspoiled as it gets.

10. Îles des Saintes, Guadeloupe

This group of small islands just south of Guadeloupe offers breathtaking views, tiny villages, and clear turquoise waters. Known for their sailing culture and scenic hikes, the Îles des Saintes feel like a chic, quiet escape. You’ll find boutique hotels, cliffside cafes, and serene beaches without a cruise ship in sight. It’s a hidden gem of the French Caribbean.

11. Vieques, Puerto Rico

Vieques is famous for its wild horses and glowing bioluminescent bay, but it still manages to fly under the radar. Just a ferry ride from mainland Puerto Rico, the island features deserted beaches, tropical forests, and a charming local feel. You can explore old military bunkers, kayak through Mosquito Bay at night, or just unwind in a hammock. Best of all, no passport is needed for U.S. citizens.

12. Culebra, Puerto Rico

Culebra is often cited as home to one of the best beaches in the world—Flamenco Beach. Yet it still feels like a well-kept secret. With limited development, crystal-clear waters, and a local population that keeps things low-key, it’s perfect for a quiet getaway. The island is accessible via ferry or small plane and offers rustic charm with world-class scenery.

13. Carriacou, Grenada

Carriacou, part of the Grenadines and governed by Grenada, is a quiet island with a strong sense of tradition. You won’t find big resorts or busy streets—just reggae bars, gentle waves, and friendly conversations. The island is ideal for snorkeling, cultural festivals, and truly unplugging. It’s small, sweet, and endlessly chill.

14. Isla de la Juventud, Cuba

Often overlooked in favor of Havana or Varadero, Isla de la Juventud is where you go to experience a quieter, more authentic Cuba. The island is dotted with quiet beaches, limestone caves, and coral reefs, perfect for diving and nature lovers. Its laid-back pace and friendly locals offer a glimpse into everyday Cuban life without the usual crowds.

15. Cat Island, Bahamas

Cat Island is one of the least-visited islands in the Bahamas—and that’s what makes it so special. It’s rugged, historic, and incredibly scenic, with hiking trails, blue holes, and endless beach walks. You won’t find high-rises or flashy nightlife here—just soulful sunsets, charming guesthouses, and the gentle rhythm of island life.